COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND POLICY IMPLEMENTATION EFFECTIVENESS: AN ANALYSIS OF STUDENT LOAN AND CASHLESS POLICIES IN NIGERIA
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.57233/ijamer.v2i1.12Keywords:
Cashless policy, community engagement, Nigeria, policy effectiveness, student loan policy, trustAbstract
Community engagement is essential for policy effectiveness, yet empirical evidence from developing countries remains limited. Nigeria's Student Loan and Cashless policies provide critical cases for examining how engagement shapes policy outcomes. This study investigates the relationship between community engagement and policy effectiveness in Nigeria through a comparative analysis of the Student Loan and Cashless policies, examining engagement levels, trust as a mediating mechanism, participation barriers, and patterns across policy types. A cross-sectional survey of 385 respondents across Nigeria was conducted. Arnstein's Ladder, Social Contract Theory, Institutional Theory, and Policy Feedback Theory were used to develop the theoretical framework. The result of the study shows that the Mean trust in government is 2.5/5, with 28% reporting "No trust." Trust is significantly lower among youth (18-30: M=2.3) than older adults (46+: M=2.9) (p=0.006). Nigerian policy engagement operates at Levels 2-4 on Arnstein's Ladder, indicating non-participation to tokenism, with 62% rating government communication ineffective and 72% reporting no feedback channels.For student loans, awareness is 78%, but application is only 18% (60-point gap). Logistic regression identified significant predictors: trust (OR=1.82), information clarity (OR=2.14), and feedback channels (OR=4.32). Factor analysis revealed three barriers explaining 81.2% of variance: Information (38.2%), Trust/Fear (24.7%), and Implementation (18.3%). Fear of debt (59%) and lack of guidance (46%) were the primary obstacles. Social media reaches 67% but yields 16.7% application; community meetings reach 23% but yield 26.2% application. Path analysis confirmed that trust mediates the relationship between transparency and participation (β = 0.38).For a cashless policy, engagement likely operates at Level 2-3, with distinctive challenges including infrastructure dependence and universal impact.Community engagement constitutes foundational infrastructure for policy effectiveness. Nigeria's implementation challenges stem not from technical design flaws but from systematic citizen exclusion. Addressing this requires moving from top-down imposition to genuine partnership and from trust assumption to explicit trust-building.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Author(s)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Google Scholar
CORE
BASE (Bielefeld Academic Search Engine)