Peer Review Policy

Double Blind Peer Review

Peer Review Policy

The International Journal of Accounting, Management and Economic Review (IJAMER) operates a structured double blind peer review process designed to ensure fairness, academic integrity and scholarly quality in all published research. Under this model, the identities of both authors and reviewers remain confidential throughout the evaluation process in order to promote objective assessment and minimize potential bias associated with author identity, institutional affiliation, or geographical background.

The peer review process plays a central role in maintaining the academic credibility of the journal by ensuring that manuscripts accepted for publication demonstrate originality, methodological soundness, analytical depth and meaningful scholarly contribution within the fields of accounting, management, finance and economics.

1Editorial Screening
›
2Reviewer Assignment
›
3Double Blind Review
›
4Editorial Decision

Initial Editorial Screening

Upon submission, manuscripts undergo an initial editorial assessment conducted by the editorial office to determine whether the study aligns with the aims, scope and academic standards of the journal. During this stage, the editorial team evaluates the manuscript for clarity of presentation, scholarly relevance, adherence to submission guidelines, referencing accuracy and overall academic quality.

Manuscripts that do not satisfy the basic scholarly or editorial requirements of the journal may be declined at this stage before external peer review. This preliminary assessment ensures that reviewers receive manuscripts suitable for scholarly evaluation.

Assignment of Reviewers

Manuscripts that successfully pass the editorial screening stage are assigned to at least two independent reviewers with appropriate subject expertise relevant to the manuscript. Reviewers are selected on the basis of academic qualification, research specialization and professional experience within the relevant field of study.

The journal is committed to ensuring reviewer independence and avoiding conflicts of interest throughout the evaluation process. Where a potential conflict of interest exists, alternative reviewers may be appointed to preserve fairness and objectivity.

Double Blind Review Process

IJAMER follows a double blind review system in which reviewers do not know the identity of the authors and authors do not know the identity of the reviewers. To facilitate this process, authors are required to remove all identifying information from the main manuscript before submission.

Author names, affiliations, acknowledgements and related identifying details should appear only on a separate cover page. This ensures manuscripts are evaluated solely on academic merit, methodological quality and scholarly contribution.

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts objectively, professionally and confidentially while providing constructive comments that contribute to the improvement of scholarly quality. Manuscripts received for review must not be shared, discussed or used for personal advantage.

During the evaluation process, reviewers assess the following:

Originality Clarity of research objectives Appropriateness of methodology Interpretation of findings Analytical rigor Relevance to the field Contribution to literature

Editorial Evaluation and Decision

Following receipt of reviewer reports, the handling editor evaluates the recommendations and prepares an editorial assessment for consideration by the Editor in Chief. Where reviewer reports differ substantially, the editorial office may invite an additional reviewer to provide further evaluation.

Based on the reviewer reports and editorial assessment, the final editorial decision may include one of the following outcomes:

Acceptance
Minor Revision
Major Revision
Rejection

Where revisions are requested, authors are expected to respond carefully to reviewer comments and submit a revised manuscript together with a response document explaining how the comments have been addressed.

Review Timeline

2–6
Weeks

The journal aims to complete the peer review process within two to six weeks depending on reviewer availability, responsiveness and the complexity of the manuscript. While the journal is committed to timely editorial decisions, priority is given to maintaining the quality, fairness and thoroughness of the review process. Authors are informed of the progress and status of their manuscripts throughout the editorial evaluation process.

Integrity of the Review Process

The journal remains committed to maintaining a fair, transparent and professionally managed peer review system. Editorial decisions are based solely on the scholarly merit, originality, relevance and methodological quality of submitted manuscripts.

The editorial office takes appropriate measures to maintain confidentiality, prevent conflicts of interest and uphold recognized standards of academic publishing ethics. Through these practices, IJAMER continues to strengthen its commitment to responsible scholarship and the publication of credible academic research within the international scholarly community.